On 30 June 2025, Bitmine Immersion announced that it would start hoarding Ether. The well-known analyst Tom Lee was to become chairman, and the money came from a private placement at 4.50 dollars per share. On the Friday before, the stock closed at 4.26 dollars. On the day of the news it closed at 33.89 dollars, three trading days later at 134.96 dollars.
Dozens of companies followed, with Solana, BNB, Tron, Dogecoin, Sui or Litecoin. The idea is tempting: the company buys the coin, and its stock rises faster than the coin itself. Strategy showed how it works with Bitcoin for years. With altcoins, though, you stack two bets: first on a coin whose future is more open than Bitcoin's, then on a company that buys it.
A turbo to riches or to ruin? Counted across 23 listed companies that hoard a coin other than Bitcoin, both are true, just not for the same people. The turbo went to whoever was in before the news. Whoever bought after it fell behind the coin the company holds in 21 of 23 cases.
The turbo was real, but over within days
Bitmine is not a one-off. Across all 23 companies, the stock rose a median 59 percent on the first trading day after the announcement. It hit its highest price a median four days after the news, within a week in 14 of 23 cases.
| Company (coin) | before the news | first close after | high | 11 Nov 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bitmine (ETH) | $4.26 | $33.89 | $134.96 (3 Jul 2025) | $19.24 |
| Sharplink (ETH) | $6.72 | $35.83 | $79.21 (29 May 2025) | $6.02 |
| DeFi Development (SOL) | $0.57 | $5.39 | $42.50 (22 May 2025) | $3.24 |
Closing prices, adjusted for stock splits.
Whoever held shares before the announcement or bought into the placement multiplied their money. Bitmine's placement buyers, in at 4.50 dollars, are still up more than fourfold today. The riches were real, but they were handed out before the news reached you.
Even buying on the first evening would have made a median 50 percent up to the high. That required knowing in advance which day the high would come. Nobody knew, and that knowledge is the price hindsight hides here.
So the question that matters is the other one: what happened to the money that came in after the news?
Buying after the news lost against the company's own coin
The calculation starts at the close of the first trading day after the announcement. That is the earliest price an ordinary investor could get. The end point is 11 November 2026.
| From the first trading day after the news | median across 23 companies |
|---|---|
| Stock, in dollars | −83.3 % |
| Coin held, in dollars | −44.8 % |
| Bitcoin, in dollars | −32.8 % |
| Stock beats its coin | 2 of 23 |
| Stock loses more than three quarters | 16 of 23 |
The coin fell, the stock fell much further. At the median, the stock is now worth about a quarter of what the same money would be worth held directly in the coin. The ruin did not come from the coin. It came from the stock that was supposed to wrap it.
That holds for the biggest name too. Bitmine now holds more than 6 million ETH. Since the first trading day after the announcement, Ether lost 17 percent and Bitmine stock 43 percent.
Two companies are ahead of their coin. SOL Strategies announced in September 2024, nine months before the wave. Its stock is up 22 percent since then while Solana is down 39 percent, but the stock has lost 97 percent from its January 2025 high. TAO Synergies lost 27 percent, TAO 49 percent. Both hold coins worth less than 100 million dollars.
That leaves the objection the title invites: maybe the problem is not the company at all, but that these are altcoins?
Altcoin or Bitcoin decided one fifth
The loss splits into two layers. The first is the coin against Bitcoin, the second the stock against its coin.
| From the first trading day after the news | beats the comparison | median |
|---|---|---|
| Coin against Bitcoin | 8 of 23 | −21.3 % |
| Stock against its coin | 2 of 23 | −75.5 % |
| Stock against Bitcoin | 1 of 23 | −75.3 % |
The altcoin layer is mixed. Ether was ahead of Bitcoin from June 2025 and behind it from late July 2025. BNB, Tron and Hyperliquid are ahead. Dogecoin lost just over half against Bitcoin, Avalanche 62 and Sui 66 percent. The stock layer is not mixed: almost every treasury stock fell far behind its coin.
Bitcoin or altcoin decided one fifth. Coin or stock decided three quarters.
That still leaves the question whether Bitcoin is the exception. It is home to the model all of these companies copied.
Strategy trailed Bitcoin in these months too
"With Bitcoin the model works. Strategy is the proof."
For the period before the wave, that is true. From 2 January 2024 to 30 June 2025, Strategy stock rose 490 percent and Bitcoin 138 percent. Holding the stock put you almost two and a half times as far ahead.
From the same 23 start dates as above, it looks different. From every one of those dates to today, Strategy trailed Bitcoin, by a median 52 percent. That is a single company on 23 closely spaced days, so it is not a second test. It does show that the split appears at the role model too.
Bitcoin's substance protects Bitcoin. It does not protect the stock of a company that hoards it.
What links both cases is the markup the stock market pays on the coins held.
The premium drives the turbo, and it runs in reverse too
How large that markup is gets measured by a ratio called mNAV: the company's market value divided by the value of the coins it holds. At an mNAV of 2, you pay two dollars for one dollar of Ether.
As long as mNAV is above 1, the turbo runs. The company sells new shares for more than the coins cost, buys coins with the money and so raises the number of coins per share. That lifts the stock, the premium grows, and the next issue gets even cheaper.
When mNAV falls below 1, this reverses. Selling new shares now costs existing shareholders money. So companies do the opposite: they sell coins and buy back their own stock. In this sample, that has already happened:
- SkyAI sold all its Solana by 16 October 2026 to pay for a buyback offer of up to 201 million dollars.
- FG Communities decided to exit on 1 July 2026 and no longer holds any Ether.
- Zone Frontier sold 463 million Dogecoin for about 33 million dollars on 20 July 2026.
- Lite Strategy sells Litecoin to buy back shares.
On top of that, Forum Markets sold most of its Ether, GameSquare sold part of its holdings and KIDZ AI switched from Solana to Hyperliquid. Seven of 23 companies have sold or switched coins. According to an analysis by DWF Ventures with data as of 21 September 2026, only four of the 20 largest treasury companies traded above the value of their coins.
Then there is the index provider MSCI. Since 11 November 2026, Sharplink, DeFi Development, Solana Company, SUI Group and BNB Standard sit on its watchlist for companies that mainly hold assets instead of running a business. Upexi leaves its indexes on 30 November.
The premium is the turbo. When it falls, the company sells exactly what you bought the stock for.
One end date, small companies, a few open timestamps
Everything is measured to a single end point, 11 November 2026. A different end date changes the numbers.
Many of these companies were small biotech, toy or gaming firms with several reverse splits before the switch. Prices are adjusted for those splits and spot-checked. For four companies the time of the announcement is open. They are treated as announced before the market opened.
Companies whose listing was called off are missing, among them The Ether Machine and Trump Media's Cronos company. Companies that listed through a shell company are counted separately because their price history is too short. Evernorth, holding XRP, has only traded since 12 October 2026, for example.
The rules for sample, entry and counting were fixed before the first run started. The comparison with Bitcoin was added afterwards, but fixed before its own run.
Want the coin? Buy the coin
Believers in Ether or Solana got the result they were betting on by holding the coin itself. The treasury stock made that result worse in 21 of 23 cases, usually by more than half.
The stock is a bet on the premium, not on the coin. And by the time the news reaches you, that premium is already priced in at the median: up 59 percent on day one, the high after four days.
Check the mNAV before buying such a stock. Above 1, you pay more than a dollar for every dollar of coin. How this plays out at a Bitcoin company is covered in Is Smarter Web Company Stock a Better Bitcoin Bet?.
The reverse direction is still open. Many of these stocks now trade below the value of their coins. Whether buying at that discount pays is the next measurement, once holdings per company are available as a daily series.
FAQ
What is a treasury company? A listed company that puts a large share of its money into one coin and holds it. Often it used to be a small company in a completely different line of business that was rebuilt with fresh money from investors.
Why start from the first trading day after the news? Because that is the earliest price an ordinary investor could get. For comparison, the calculation also runs from the close before the announcement. Then 5 of 23 stocks are ahead of their coin, among them Bitmine, Sharplink and DeFi Development. Only existing shareholders and placement buyers got that price, though.
Why against the coin and not just in dollars? Because the question is whether the stock was the better way into the coin. In dollars almost everything lost, Bitcoin included. The comparison with the coin shows what the stock itself cost.
Which companies are included? Ether: Bitmine, Sharplink, Bit Digital, Forum Markets, FG Communities, GameSquare. Solana: Forward Industries, DeFi Development, Upexi, Solana Company, SkyAI, Solmate, KIDZ AI, SOL Strategies. Plus Hyperion DeFi (HYPE), BNB Standard (formerly CEA Industries) and Nano Labs (BNB), Tron Inc (TRX), Zone Frontier (DOGE), AVAX One (AVAX), SUI Group (SUI), TAO Synergies (TAO) and Lite Strategy (LTC). Every listed company with a price history from the announcement on, regardless of outcome.
Where does the data come from? Stock prices from Yahoo Finance, adjusted for splits; coin prices as Binance daily closes, Hyperliquid via the Hyperliquid API. Announcement dates and holdings from filings with the US regulator SEC and company releases. Announcements and holdings retrieved on 22 and 23 October 2026, prices on 12 November 2026.
Sources
- Prices: Yahoo Finance (stocks, daily close, split-adjusted), Binance (coins, daily close UTC), Hyperliquid API (HYPE), September 2024 to 11 November 2026, retrieved 12 November 2026; all returns and counts are own calculations
- Announcements and holdings: company filings with the SEC (EDGAR), among them Bitmine Immersion, 8-K of 30 June 2025 and holdings update of October 2026
- SkyAI: release on selling all its Solana, October 2026
- Zone Frontier: prospectus supplement (424B5) on the Dogecoin sale, July 2026
- FG Communities: exit decision of 1 July 2026
- DWF Ventures, analysis of the 20 largest treasury companies, data as of 21 September 2026, as reported by Cointelegraph and Crypto Briefing
- MSCI: Final List of MSCI GIMI Securities Impacted by the Non-Operating Screening Methodology, 11 November 2026 (msci.com/index-consultations)
Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not a forecast — historical patterns are no promise.
Study the Past — Improve your Future 🥋