Backtesting ArenaBacktesting Arena
← Back to blog

We Rebuilt Our Worst Strategy Correctly — It Worked — and Cut It Anyway

Our Bollinger Squeeze strategy lost to Buy & Hold by double digits on crypto. Before deleting it, we rebuilt it to the modern standard (TTM Squeeze). The rebuild turned positive — and we retired it anyway. Why "it works now" isn't enough.

Backtesting Arena·July 1, 2026·3 min read·54 views
We Rebuilt Our Worst Strategy Correctly — It Worked — and Cut It Anyway

Auditing 40,000 backtests, one strategy was the worst by a clear margin: our Bollinger Band Squeeze. On crypto — its best asset class — it beat Avg Buy & Hold on just 11 of 32 pairs, a median of about −9 percentage points, and run-weighted closer to −21. Worse than a coin flip.

Most platforms would quietly leave that on the menu or quietly delete it. We did neither. We asked: is the concept bad, or is our implementation bad?

Why our version was bad

Our bb_squeeze was a dated, naive reading:

  • a fixed absolute threshold for how "tight" the bands are, which doesn't adapt to crypto's volatility,
  • entry on the breakout above the upper band (you buy the spike),
  • exit at the middle band (you sell into every normal pullback).

That structure systematically buys highs and sells into noise. A median of −21 points — worse than random — is exactly that signature.

The rebuild

We implemented the modern standard, John Carter's TTM Squeeze:

  • Bollinger Bands inside the Keltner Channels define the squeeze,
  • a momentum oscillator sets the direction,
  • you ride the trend and exit when momentum dies — not at the middle band.

Same concept, current logic. Result across eight crypto pairs (pre-cost):

VariantMedian ΔCAGR vs B&Hbeats B&H
v1 (old)−15.9 pp2 of 8
TTM rebuild+8.6 pp6 of 8

A swing of about 25 points from correct logic alone. The squeeze concept works on crypto — our old code was the bottleneck, not the idea.

The twist: momentum was the edge, not the squeeze

We also tested pure momentum with no squeeze gate. It did even better: +12.8 pp.

So the squeeze wasn't the source of the edge. It just halved the trade count (33 vs 69). On crypto the edge was momentum all along — the squeeze is a cost/selectivity filter, not an alpha source.

Why we're cutting it anyway

Here's the discipline. The repaired +8.6 still sits below the strategies we already run: a simple EMA cross beats Buy & Hold on crypto by a median of +24 points, Supertrend by +23 — both with fewer trades. A correctly rebuilt, mediocre duplicate of something we already do better is still ballast.

So we're retiring it — no rebuild into the product. The "config or concept?" question is answered (config), but the answer doesn't change the decision: we crystallize the best strategies instead of carrying every one.

What happens to the data

The strategy leaves the backtester but stays visible in Strategy Insights and the Strategy Library — tagged with the retirement finding and the numbers. The accumulated data and the insight (including "the squeeze is a cost filter, not an edge") remain part of the product.

What Backtesting Arena contributes here

We test our own strategies hard enough to repair one, see that it works, and cut it anyway because we already have better. That is a hard call — and it's why our strategy set stays short and sharp instead of long and diluted.

FAQ

If the rebuild works, why not ship it? Because +8.6 vs B&H is positive but mediocre. EMA cross (+24) and Supertrend (+23) deliver more return with fewer trades. A second, weaker trend strategy is ballast, not value.

Was the old version a bug? No, but dated: fixed volatility threshold + breakout entry / middle-band exit. Not a classic error, but a naive implementation that buys spikes and sells pullbacks in trending crypto.

What does "the squeeze is a cost filter" mean? Pure momentum (no squeeze) delivered more return (+12.8) but with twice the trades. The squeeze halves the trades for slightly less return — it saves costs but generates no edge of its own.

Can I still see the data? Yes — Strategy Insights + Strategy Library, tagged as retired, with the numbers. It's just no longer offered in the backtester.

Will you build the TTM Squeeze later after all? Only if a version clears the bar against our roster (EMA cross / Supertrend). We won't build a mid-pack duplicate.

Try it yourself

Run the backtest with your own parameters and time ranges.

Run backtest →

More on this topic

Strategy

Does the Ichimoku Cloud Work on Crypto? Buying Only Above the Cloud Earned Less on All Ten Large Coins

Backtesting Arenatradingstrategies.work

Ichimoku is usually traded with 9, 26 and 52 and with the rule "only buy above the cloud". Both were tested on crypto from 2018 to October 2026. The cloud rule lowered the result on all ten of today's largest coins, and on bitcoin and ether the traditional numbers did no better than randomly drawn ones. What that means for your settings.

Trend followingBacktestingMethodology+1
Oct 15, 20261 min
Strategy

When should you switch off a trading strategy? Popular kill rules flag good strategies almost as often as bad ones

Backtesting Arenatradingstrategies.work

A popular framework says: cut a strategy's position in half when its 90-day Sharpe drops below the backtest's 5th percentile, pause it at 1.5x the backtest drawdown. Simulated, those rules cut eight in ten healthy strategies to half size within three years and leave four in five strategies without any edge running through their first year. What to check instead.

Risk managementBacktestingMethodology+2
Oct 12, 20261 min
Strategy

Is the Anchored VWAP Strategy Worth It? Checked Against Six Years of Bitcoin

Backtesting Arenatradingstrategies.work

The anchored VWAP strategy draws an average-price line from a starting point you pick, such as the last low, and buys while price stays above it. Its result depends on that starting point. On six years of Bitcoin, none of five common anchor rules placed the line better than chance, and the 52-week low did worse than 99 percent of random anchors. Why that happens, why the charts still look convincing, and what to use instead.

BacktestingMethodologyTrend following+1
Oct 7, 20261 min
Strategy

A Backtest With a 100% Win Rate: We're Testing It — Rules Set Before We Compute

Backtesting Arenatradingstrategies.work

A backtest claiming a 100% win rate and 34 million percent returns is circulating. We're rebuilding it — and setting the rules before we compute.

BacktestingLook-ahead biasMethodology
Jul 14, 20261 min
📬

Don't miss new blog posts

One short email per new post — strategies, backtests, market analysis. No spam, unsubscribe with one click anytime.

By subscribing you accept our privacy policy. We use Resend for delivery. Double opt-in confirmation required.

Comments (0)

Join free to post comments.

Sign up →

No comments yet. Be the first!