Backtesting Arena

Backtesting Arena

Back to blog

A Tale of Bulls, Bears and Whales

A market fable in two acts — and what it is meant to teach.

Backtesting Arena·September 4, 2026·7 min read·1 views
A Tale of Bulls, Bears and Whales

What follows is not a forecast. It is a pattern, told as a story, because the pattern is easier to recognize in a story than in a chart. Read it once for the plot. Read the second half for the mechanics.

ACT ONE — THE BULLS

September 2025. The market is frustrated. Bitcoin isn't performing, and anyone who tried altcoins got their fingers burned. No altseason. The market just crawls sideways, trades in a range, good news doesn't land anymore, every rally gets sold into immediately.

But there's still the BOT — the blow-off top that always comes in the post-halving year. That's what makes all of this worth it. That's where the big payday is.

End of September, price slips again, stalls, waits a few days. Some give up in frustration. But most are still strung tight as a bowstring.

And then — what's this? Price is climbing. A little more every day. Should we get back in? It's early October. Here we go.

The herd is euphoric, scraping together every last cent it can find, and when there's nothing left, it levers up hard. Price keeps climbing. No pullback. A goddamn lockout rally.

We're just short of the ATH. And then? ATH broken. Euphoria. Now the rocket lifts off — a magnificent 1.5% above the old high.

But wait. A pullback? Over a few days, a little correction. Just a small storm cloud, nothing more. The whole herd is standing at the edge of the cliff and doesn't know it.

People go to sleep. Then comes the spark that lights the mixture. First price dips gently, then it rips straight through the order books and liquidates everything that isn't nailed down.

The bulls are slaughtered so thoroughly they won't recover for a long time. Their unshakeable faith in a green post-halving year and a Q4 blow-off top made them easy prey. For months they ignored the warning signs: great news moved nothing, bad news moved price down instantly.

ACT TWO — THE BEARS

  1. After the bull slaughter of 10/10, more and more bears appear on the scene. They tell the old stories, how it used to be. They bring the prophecy of the bear market, draw their lines and say: look, break below this and the bull is history.

At first only a few are convinced. Then, in early 2026, the next liquidation cascade hits. More and more bulls fall over. The narrative seems to be right.

A few incorrigible bulls are still walking around. More and more they get laughed at — exactly the way they laughed at the bears back in late 2025.

There, the countermove. It was only a pause. And then the next fat liquidation cascade. We're already at –50%.

Now almost nobody doubts the bear market anymore. Except those who never cared, because they started feeding so early that no winter can touch them.

And then, after endless back and forth, the first tender spring flowers. Some start feeling bullish again. And it continues, a whole month long. But there, it stalls again. The early risers are still standing there in disbelief when the next winter storm breaks over them and destroys their hope.

The bears are triumphant. They've converted so many now that they sit firmly in the saddle.

But what's this? Just below the last low, nothing happens. What's going on? We should be far lower by now. Two months: nothing.

The bears remain certain. Payday is coming. In October, because it always has. They sit on the sidelines and watch. Nothing can shake them — as little as anything could shake the bulls in 2025.

The whole time, the whales are swimming in the sea, feeding on the remains of the bulls. Through their mouthpieces they spread the story: bears, your reward is coming. In October you'll eat well.

Here and there another early bull or late bear tips over, the remains wash into the sea and the whales eat. But it gets less every day. The whales grow impatient, more and more of them arrive wanting to feed. It's only August, and it looks like there isn't enough left for everyone.

Meanwhile the bears have prepared for payday. The money bags are ready, the greed is growing. They lever up — that makes the certain payday even richer, compensation for a completely botched bull market.

The whales, though, notice something: it's not just that no food is coming in, it's that the only thing being sold now is borrowed. And they can only feed if price goes up. So they wait, and they fan the belief in the October bottom — exactly as they did in 2025.

Then the moment comes. A favorable news backdrop, and they go. They light the pile — and it works: the largest short squeeze in history.

It lasts three days. And then? Some sell again, some for the first time. Which only makes the October payday bigger. The bears already see the bulls back on the chopping block — but they have nothing left to offer the whales.

Price drifts again. Almost two weeks. Then the next blow. The bears are patient, they believe their payday must come. But the number of whales and bulls is rising. There, the two megawhales are feeding again. The old bulls keep feeding too.

And the great feeding and redistribution has been running for two and a half years now.

WHAT THE FABLE IS ACTUALLY ABOUT

THE SETUP — A CALENDAR IS NOT A THESIS

Both sides in this story hold the same kind of belief, and it is not a belief about price. It is a belief about a date. Post-halving year, therefore green. October, therefore payday. Neither statement contains a mechanism, a condition, or a way to be wrong. It is a schedule wearing the costume of an argument.

A thesis you cannot falsify is not a thesis. It is collateral, and someone else will eventually collect it.

THE TELL — WHEN GOOD NEWS STOPS WORKING

The most useful signal in Act One appears months before the liquidation, and it costs nothing to observe: great news no longer moves price, bad news moves it immediately.

That asymmetry describes positioning, not sentiment. It means the buyers who were going to buy have already bought, and the only remaining flow that can be triggered is the exit. Every participant in the story could see this. Almost none acted on it, because the calendar said otherwise.

THE MECHANISM — LIQUIDITY LIVES WHERE THE STOPS ARE

The 10/10 cascade did not happen because the news was bad. It happened because leverage had accumulated in a place where a small move became a forced move.

Large size cannot be filled into a quiet market. It needs a counterparty, and forced liquidation manufactures one. This is why the violent moves cluster around the levels everyone can see, and why "it went exactly where the liquidation map said" is a description of the mechanism rather than a conspiracy.

THE MIRROR — THE BEARS BECOME THE BULLS

Act Two is Act One with the sign flipped. Same posture, same certainty, same calendar, opposite direction. The bears who correctly called 10/10 then converted a good call into an identity, levered it up, and stood in exactly the position they had just profited from.

Being right once is the most expensive thing that can happen to an undisciplined thesis.

THE FUEL — BORROWED SUPPLY IS NOT SUPPLY

The turn in Act Two hinges on a detail that is easy to miss: when the selling is short selling, the sold coins have to be bought back. That is not distribution, it is deferred demand with a deadline attached.

A market where the marginal seller is borrowing has run out of things to feed on downside. From that point, the path of least resistance inverts — not because anyone decided it should, but because there is nothing left below and a mandatory buyer above.

THE TRAP — CONSENSUS IS THE THING THAT GETS PRICED

History rhymes, but it often sets traps. The trap is never the pattern itself. It is the crowd that memorized the pattern.

A seasonal edge that everyone knows about is front-run, positioned into, and then used as a liquidity pool by the people on the other side. The more reliable a date looks, the more crowded the seats around it, and the less the date can pay.

THE CLOSING QUESTION

So — are you one of the bears who's certain payday has to come in October, at much lower prices?

When everyone knows exactly how it's going to play out, when everyone knows the train has only so many seats — do you wait until they all want in at the same time? Or do you get there early, take your seat, and wait patiently for the train to leave?

The people in this story who came out fine were never the ones who guessed the month. They were the ones who started feeding so early that no winter could touch them.

Study the Past — Improve your Future 🥋

Try it yourself

Run the backtest with your own parameters and time ranges.

Run backtest →
📬

Don't miss new blog posts

One short email per new post — strategies, backtests, market analysis. No spam, unsubscribe with one click anytime.

By subscribing you accept our privacy policy. We use Resend for delivery. Double opt-in confirmation required.

Comments (0)

Join free to post comments.

Sign up →

No comments yet. Be the first!